Overcoming Bias in Nursing Leadership

Bias can impact decision-making, team dynamics, and ultimately, patient care. It is pivotal to overcoming bias in nursing leadership to fostering a fair, inclusive, and supportive environment for both staff and patients.

Implicit or unconscious bias is not intentional, but it has a detrimental impact. Implicit bias in nursing affects nurses’ quality of life and patient outcomes.

Types of Bias:

1. Implicit bias (unconscious)
2. Explicit bias (conscious)
3. Confirmation bias (selective information)
4. Anchoring bias (relying on initial information)
5. Affinity bias (favoring similar individuals)

Impact of Bias in Nursing Leadership:

1. Poor decision-making
2. Inequitable resource allocation
3. Stereotyping and discrimination
4. Decreased diversity and inclusion
5. Negative impact on patient outcomes

Impact In the Workplace

Implicit bias is visible in work satisfaction, morale, and career development. Bias such as racism in nursing can affect:

• Who attends and graduates from nursing school
• Who is selected for interviews, advanced in the hiring process, and hired
• Team communication (such as who is interrupted or talked over)
• Who is formally or informally mentored and sponsored
• Who is encouraged to pursue further education or advancement opportunities
• Salary and other compensation
• Bullying, teasing, hazing, or other staff negative behavior
• Stress, burnout, and well-being
• Staff retention

Impact In Patient Care & Bedside Manner

Bias also causes healthcare disparities for patients based on their race, ethnicity, sex and gender, sexual identity, weight, socioeconomic status, and age:

• Bedside manner and patient communication (such as talking down to patients or family members or treating them as though they are not intelligent and competent)
• Pain management (such as the stereotype that Black people are less sensitive to pain than others or that lower-income patients are more likely to be drug seekers, resulting in those patients not receiving care for their pain.)
• Whether patients are believed and listened to when they first report symptoms or causes (that patients with historically excluded identities are not believed)
• How thoroughly a clinician explains information to a patient (that clinicians may leave out nuances of the patient’s condition or the consequences of decisions or omit or push a patient toward or away from certain interventions or options)
• Assumptions about compliance (often that patients would have no reason for not complying or that they do not or would not comply with treatment plans)
• Not understanding or addressing barriers to care (that clinicians misunderstand the causes for patients’ decisions in managing their health, possibly resulting in their recommending treatments that cannot effectively address the patient needs and concerns)
• Diagnoses (such as women or patients from other groups burdened with negative stereotypes being told “it’s all in your head” or having conditions dismissed as depression — and then allowing that depression to remain unaddressed)
• Stereotypes (such as people who are overweight, among other characteristics and identities, being believed to be lazy and undisciplined)

Strategies to help nursing leaders recognize and reduce bias:

1. Self-Reflection and Awareness
   • Engage in Self-Reflection: Leaders should regularly reflect on their own attitudes, assumptions, and behaviors. This helps identify any biases that may affect their leadership style.
   • Bias Assessment Tools: Tools like the Implicit Association Test (IAT) can help uncover unconscious biases and provide insight into personal prejudices that may influence leadership decisions.
2. Training and Workshops
   • Cultural Competency Training: This helps leaders understand and respect cultural differences and reduces stereotypes.
   • Sensitivity Workshops: Regular training sessions can help leaders recognize and counteract biases, and encourage empathy and inclusivity.
3. Promote Open Dialogue
   • Create Safe Spaces: Leaders should foster an environment where team members feel comfortable discussing issues related to bias or discrimination.
   • Active Listening: Leaders can practice active listening, which allows them to understand diverse perspectives and build trust with their team members.
4. Standardize Evaluation Tools
   • Objective Evaluation: Use standardized criteria and structured interviews for performance evaluations to prevent biases from influencing decisions.
   • Accountability for Decisions: Leaders should document their decision-making processes to ensure transparency and reduce subjective judgment.
5. Analysis and Feedback
   • Collect and Review Data: Regularly review data on hiring, promotions, and patient outcomes to identify any patterns that may indicate bias.
   • Solicit Feedback from Staff: Encourage anonymous feedback on leadership practices. This can highlight potential biases that leaders might not have noticed.
6. Model Inclusive Behaviours
   • Lead by Example: Nursing leaders set the tone for inclusivity. They can model respectful and unbiased behavior, which encourages their teams to do the same.
   • Acknowledge and Address Biases Publicly: When leaders address and correct their own biases, it shows commitment to improvement and fosters an environment of growth and accountability.
7. Cultivate an Inclusive Culture
   • Celebrate Diversity: Recognizing and celebrating diverse backgrounds and perspectives can help foster an environment where everyone feels valued.
   • Team-Building Exercises: Activities that bring people together can break down preconceived notions and encourage collaboration across diverse groups.
8. Establish Bias-Reduction Policies
   • Clear Policies: Having clear policies and a zero-tolerance approach to discrimination encourages a culture of fairness.
   • Support Systems: Providing anonymous reporting channels for discrimination or bias concerns helps create a safer work environment.
   Overcoming bias is an ongoing effort, and consistency in these practices is key to fostering long-term change in healthcare settings.

Specific Strategies for Overcoming Bias:

1.Self-Awareness Strategies:

1. Reflect on personal values and biases
2. Identify triggers for biased thinking
3. Seek feedback from others
4. Practice mindfulness and self-reflection
5. Engage in journaling or self-assessment exercises

2.Education and Training Strategies:

1. Diversity and inclusion workshops
2. Unconscious bias training
3. Cultural competence education
4. Microaggression training
5. Leadership development programs

3.Decision-Making Strategies:

1. Use data-driven decision-making
2. Consider multiple perspectives
3. Avoid anchoring bias (relying on initial information)
4. Use devil’s advocacy technique
5. Encourage diverse input

4.Communication Strategies:

1. Active listening
2. Open and transparent communication
3. Avoid language that perpetuates stereotypes
4. Use inclusive language
5. Encourage feedback and concerns

5.Leadership Strategies:

1. Lead by example
2. Foster a culture of inclusivity
3. Develop diverse leadership teams
4. Mentor and sponsor underrepresented groups
5. Hold leaders accountable for bias

6.Organizational Strategies:

1. Develop diversity and inclusion policies
2. Establish bias reporting mechanisms
3. Provide resources for underrepresented groups
4. Conduct regular climate surveys
5. Develop and implement bias-reducing initiatives

REFERENCES

1. Agarwal, P. Here Is Why Organisations Need to Be Conscious of Unconscious Bias. August 2018. Forbes Available at: https://www.forbes.com/sites/pragyaagarwaleurope/2018/08/26/here-is-why-organisations-need-to-be-conscious-of-unconscious-bias/?sh=41a0b710726b
2. Nordell, J. The End of Bias: A Beginning: The New Science of Overcoming Unconscious Bias Henry Holt and Company, New York, NY, 2021
3. Sportsman, S. Implicit Bias: Does it Impact Nursing Education? June 2019. Collaborative Momentum Consulting Available at: https://collaborativemomentum.com/2019/06/19/implicit-bias-does-it-impact-nursing-education/
4. Haghighi, A. Biases in healthcare: An overview. (2023). Medical News Today Insights into Nurses’ Experiences and Perceptions of Discrimination. (2023). Robert Wood Johnson Foundation
5. Dovidio JF, Fiske ST. Under the radar: how unexamined biases in decision-making processes in clinical interactions can contribute to health care disparities. Am J Public Health. 2012;102(5):945-952.

Stories are the threads that bind us; through them, we understand each other, grow, and heal.

JOHN NOORD

Connect with “Nurses Lab Editorial Team”

I hope you found this information helpful. Do you have any questions or comments? Kindly write in comments section. Subscribe the Blog with your email so you can stay updated on upcoming events and the latest articles.