SBAR vs ISBAR which is more Adaptable in Clinical Practice

SBAR vs ISBAR

SBAR (Situation, Background, Assessment, Recommendation) and ISBAR (Identification, Situation, Background, Assessment, Recommendation) are both widely used communication frameworks in clinical practice.

Similarities:

1. Both SBAR and ISBAR aim to standardize communication, reducing errors and improving patient safety.
2. Both frameworks emphasize clear, concise, and structured communication.
3. Both include Assessment and Recommendation components.

Differences:

1. Identification (ISBAR): Adds an initial step to identify the patient, provider, and purpose of the communication.
2. Situation (SBAR/ISBAR): Describes the current situation or problem.
3. Background (SBAR/ISBAR): Provides relevant context and history.
4. Assessment (SBAR/ISBAR): Analyzes the situation and provides a diagnosis or conclusion.
5. Recommendation (SBAR/ISBAR): Offers a specific action or plan.

Adaptability in Clinical Practice:

ISBAR may be more adaptable in:

1. High-acuity settings (e.g., ICU, ED) where rapid identification is crucial.
2. Situations requiring immediate attention (e.g., code blues).
3. Telemedicine or phone communications where visual cues are absent.

SBAR may be more suitable for:

1. Routine handoffs or reports.
2. Less urgent situations where context is more important.
3. Interdisciplinary team communications.

Why ISBAR might be preferred:

1. Enhanced patient safety through clear identification.
2. Reduced errors due to misidentification.
3. Improved clarity in high-pressure situations.

Why SBAR remains popular:

1. Simplified structure.
2. Easier to remember and implement.
3. Effective for routine communications.

Ultimately, the choice between SBAR and ISBAR depends on:

1. Clinical context.
2. Organizational policies.
3. Provider preference.
4. Communication culture.

Recommendations:

1. Use ISBAR in high-acuity or urgent situations.
2. Use SBAR for routine handoffs or reports.
3. Adapt frameworks to suit specific clinical needs.
4. Provide education and training on both frameworks.

Implementing SBAR/ISBAR in Specific Clinical Settings:

Emergency Department (ED):

1. Use ISBAR for urgent situations (e.g., trauma, cardiac arrest).
2. Utilize SBAR for non-urgent patient handoffs.
3. Implement electronic SBAR/ISBAR templates for efficient communication.

Intensive Care Unit (ICU):

1. Use ISBAR for high-acuity patient reports.
2. Emphasize clear identification and situation assessment.
3. Incorporate SBAR into daily rounds and handoffs.

Operating Room (OR):

1. Utilize ISBAR for pre-operative briefings.
2. Focus on clear communication of patient identity, procedure, and anesthesia plan.
3. Implement SBAR for post-operative handoffs.

Medical-Surgical Units:

1. Use SBAR for routine patient handoffs.
2. Emphasize clear communication of patient status, medications, and treatment plans.
3. Incorporate ISBAR for urgent situations (e.g., code blues).

Pediatric and Neonatal Units:

1. Use ISBAR for high-acuity patient reports.
2. Emphasize clear communication of patient identity, weight, and medical history.
3. Incorporate SBAR into daily rounds and handoffs.

Mental Health Units:

1. Utilize SBAR for routine patient handoffs.
2. Focus on clear communication of patient mental status, treatment plans, and safety concerns.
3. Incorporate ISBAR for crisis situations.

Implementation Strategies:

1. Provide education and training on SBAR/ISBAR.
2. Develop standardized communication protocols.
3. Use electronic templates and communication tools.
4. Conduct regular drills and simulations.
5. Monitor and evaluate communication effectiveness.

Challenges and Solutions:

1. Resistance to change: Engage stakeholders, provide training.
2. Time constraints: Streamline communication processes.
3. Information overload: Focus on key information.

Customizing SBAR/ISBAR for Specific Patient Populations:

Paediatrics:

1. Include patient weight, age, and medical history.
2. Emphasize allergy and medication information.
3. Use simple language for family-centered care.

Gerontology:

1. Focus on cognitive and functional status.
2. Include medication lists and potential interactions.
3. Consider advanced care planning and end-of-life discussions.

Mental Health:

1. Include mental status, treatment plans, and safety concerns.
2. Emphasize medication adherence and side effects.
3. Use non-judgmental language and person-centered approach.

Neonatology:

1. Include birth weight, gestational age, and medical history.
2. Focus on vital signs, respiratory status, and nutrition.
3. Use precise language for medication and treatment plans.

Oncology:

1. Include cancer diagnosis, stage, and treatment plan.
2. Focus on symptom management and pain control.
3. Emphasize psychosocial support and patient-centered care.

Critical Care:

1. Include vital signs, lab results, and medical history.
2. Focus on life-sustaining interventions and code status.
3. Use clear language for complex medical information.

Customization Strategies:

1. Involve interdisciplinary teams in development.
2. Conduct patient and family feedback sessions.
3. Review and revise templates regularly.
4. Incorporate electronic health records (EHRs) integration.
5. Provide education and training on customized SBAR/ISBAR.

REFERENCES:

1. Pakcheshm B, Bagheri I, Kalani Z. The impact of using “ISBAR” standard checklist on nursing clinical handoff in coronary care units. NPT. 2020;7(4):266-274.
2. Raeisi A, Rarani MA, Soltani F. Challenges of patient handover process in healthcare services: A systematic review. Journal of Education Promotion.2019;8:173.
3. SBAR. Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, Rockville, MD. https://www.ahrq.gov/teamstepps-program/curriculum/communication/tools/sbar.html
4. Shah, Yousaf & Alinier, Guillaume & Pillay, Yugan. (2016). Clinical handover between paramedics and emergency department staff: SBAR and IMIST-AMBO acronyms. International Paramedic Practice. 6. 37-44. 10.12968/ippr.2016.6.2.37.

Stories are the threads that bind us; through them, we understand each other, grow, and heal.

JOHN NOORD

Connect with “Nurses Lab Editorial Team”

I hope you found this information helpful. Do you have any questions or comments? Kindly write in comments section. Subscribe the Blog with your email so you can stay updated on upcoming events and the latest articles.