Difference between ICU Nurse & ER Nurse – Which Speciality to Choose

ICU Nurse:

What is an ICU Nurse?

Intensive Care Unit (ICU) nurses treat patients who require the highest acuity of care in a very structured and controlled setting, the Intensive Care Unit.

In order to treat the most critical patients in the most thorough manner, critical care nurses use their specialized skills and extensive knowledge of disease pathology to provide interventions that sustain life.

Without ICU nurses, healthcare systems would be unable to accept trauma patients, end-of-life patients, and others who require highly specialized care. These nurses are specially trained and often cannot be replaced unless an individual has similar training and credentials.

What Does an ICU Nurse Do?

They care for the most fragile of patients who hang on to life by a thread. Most patients in the ICU are intubated, ventilated, and on life-sustaining medication drips at the very least.

Nurses need to be able to pre-emptively recognize signs of decompensation and act swiftly on them. They are advocates for their patients and work closely with the intensive care team to treat their patients. The environment is structured, high acuity, and multifaceted. 

More specifically, ICU nurses perform a variety of tasks and have numerous job responsibilities. These will vary depending on the healthcare system, but generally,

ICU nurses perform the following specific duties:

• Collaborate with healthcare professionals to provide holistic care to patients.
• Educate patients and their families on diagnosis, medications, and other information
• Cleaning and bandaging patient wounds
• Tracking life support equipment
• Immediately respond to changes in the patient’s condition.
• Evaluating vital signs such as HR, RR, Arrythmias, CVP, CO etc
• Administering medications
• Acting as a patient’s advocate
• Provide comfort and prevent suffering
• Infusing blood products and monitoring patients for reaction
• Caring for the patient’s body immediately after death
• Identifying patient’s needs according to their age and level of consciousness and creating a care plan to meet them
• Complete paperwork prior to transferring or discharging a patient
• Respond to medical emergencies in the unit
• Supporting a compassionate and therapeutic environment for critically ill patients

Considerations

1. Care for critically ill patients requiring close monitoring.
2. Focus on long-term patient management (hours to days).
3. Patients typically have life-threatening conditions (e.g., sepsis, respiratory failure).
4. Emphasis on:
   • Hemodynamic monitoring.
   • Mechanical ventilation management.
   • Medication titration.
   • Family support and education.
5. Typical patient-to-nurse ratio: 1-2:1.

ER Nurse:

What is an ER Nurse?

Emergency room nurses are licensed registered nurses who treat patients coming through hospital emergency departments. ER nurse patients come from all ages and backgrounds and suffer from various conditions. Consequently, ER nurses must prepare to treat a wide range of ailments, including trauma, injury, and acute-onset conditions.

What Does an ER Nurse Do?

From heart attacks to strokes, gunshot wounds, motor vehicle accidents, or fractured bones, ER nurses see it all.

ER nurses learn to quickly triage patients based on immediate observation and acute assessment skills, then treat symptoms in order of life-threatening priority.

They may immediately start CPR to reverse cardiopulmonary arrest, start slamming blood products for a hemorrhaging patient, or work to quickly discover underlying medical conditions that are less apparent. 

Specific ER nurse duties include the following:

• Administering blood products, medications, and vaccinations 
• Assisting in the care of traumas, cardiac arrests, strokes, sexual assaults, and conscious sedation
• Cleaning and dressing wounds
• Conducting cardiopulmonary resuscitation, rescue breathing, or bag-valve-mask ventilation
• Discharging medically stable patients
• Educating patients, families, and caregivers about their disease and treatment plan
• Performing tracheostomies and intubations
• Placing Intravenous lines
• Responding to emergency situations throughout the hospital
• Setting broken bones
• Stabilizing trauma patients
• Treating critical injuries, allergic reactions, and trauma
• Triaging patients upon arrival to the emergency room

Considerations

1. Care for patients with acute, urgent, or emergent conditions.
2. Focus on rapid assessment, stabilization, and disposition (minutes to hours).
3. Patients may have varied conditions (e.g., trauma, cardiac arrest, minor injuries).
4. Emphasis on:
   • Rapid assessment and prioritization.
   • Emergency procedures (e.g., CPR, intubation).
   • Diagnostic testing and imaging.
   • Quick decision-making.
5. Typical patient-to-nurse ratio: 3-5:1.

Key Differences:

1. Patient acuity: ICU patients are generally more critically ill.
2. Time frame: ICU care is longer-term, while ER care is rapid and urgent.
3. Skill set: ICU nurses focus on complex, ongoing management; ER nurses focus on rapid assessment and intervention.
4. Environment: ICU is a controlled, monitored environment; ER is fast-paced and unpredictable.
5. Patient interaction: ICU nurses often develop close relationships with patients and families; ER nurses interact briefly with patients and families.

Similarities:

1. Both require strong critical thinking and problem-solving skills.
2. Both involve collaboration with interdisciplinary teams.
3. Both demand excellent communication and patient advocacy skills.
4. Both require adaptability and flexibility.
5. Both involve ongoing education and training.

Skills and Responsibilities

ICU Nurses:

• They have knowledge of using advanced monitoring equipment is such as ventilators.
• Administer medication, focus on comprehensive care plans, give IVs, and document patient progress who are in ICU.
• They have effective communication skills and able to communicate with other health care workers and the patient’s family.
• They provide emotional support to the patient and their family members and educate them about the treatments.
• ICU nurses have strong critical thinking and problem-solving skills during stressful situations.

ER Nurses:

• Mastery in triage protocols that is to provide immediate care to the patients who are in serious condition and require urgent care.
• They have skill in performing lifesaving procedures such as defibrillations, trauma stabilization and intubations.
• They have effective communication skills and collaborate with teamwork to stabilize the patient.

REFERENCES

1. Skillgigs, ER Nurses vs ICU Nurses: Exploring the Key Differences in Roles and Responsibilities retrieved from https://skillgigs.com/career-advice/healthcare-talent/er-nurses-vs-icu-nurses-exploring-the-key-differences-in-roles-and-responsibilities/
2. Ariella Jolly, Intensive Care Unit Nurse vs Emergency Department Nurse: What’s the Difference? https://www.incrediblehealth.com/blog/intensive-care-unit-nurse-vs-emergency-nurse/
3. Chief Editor, TNNMC,ER Nurse Vs. ICU Nurse: What’s The Difference? retrieved from https://www.tnnmc.org/er-nurse-vs-icu-nurse-whats-the-difference/

Stories are the threads that bind us; through them, we understand each other, grow, and heal.

JOHN NOORD

Connect with “Nurses Lab Editorial Team”

I hope you found this information helpful. Do you have any questions or comments? Kindly write in comments section. Subscribe the Blog with your email so you can stay updated on upcoming events and the latest articles.